Discussion:
Sinusitis Linked to Microbial Diversity
(too old to reply)
asdfasdf
2012-09-15 02:37:32 UTC
Permalink
This seems like it may hold some promise...

http://www.ucsf.edu/news/2012/09/12718/sinusitis-linked-microbial-diversity

Sinusitis Linked to Microbial Diversity
UCSF Study Suggests New Approach for Dealing with Common Ailment
Share this story:
Share
Print
By Jason Bardi on September 12, 2012
Email

A common bacteria ever-present on the human skin and previously
considered harmless, may, in fact, be the culprit behind chronic
sinusitis, a painful, recurring swelling of the sinuses that strikes
more than one in ten Americans each year, according to a study by
scientists at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF).
Susan Lynch, PhD

Susan Lynch, PhD

The team reports this week in the journal Science Translational Medicine
that sinusitis may be linked to the loss of normal microbial diversity
within the sinuses following an infection and the subsequent
colonization of the sinuses by the culprit bacterium, which is called
Corynebacterium tuberculostearicum.

In their study, the researchers compared the microbial communities in
samples from the sinuses of 10 patients with sinusitis and from 10
healthy people, and showed that the sinusitis patients lacked a slew of
bacteria that were present in the healthy individuals. The patients also
had large increases in the amount of Corynebacterium tuberculostearicum
in their sinuses, which are located in the forehead, cheeks and eyes.

The team also identified a common bacterium found within the sinuses of
healthy people called Lactobacillus sakei that seems to help the body
naturally ward off sinusitis. In laboratory experiments, inoculating
mice with this one bacterium defended them against the condition.

“Presumably these are sinus-protective species,” said Susan Lynch, PhD,
an associate professor of medicine and director of the Colitis and
Crohn’s Disease Microbiome Research Core at UCSF.

What it all suggests, she added, is that the sinuses are home to a
diverse “microbiome” that includes protective bacteria. These “microbial
shields” are lost during chronic sinusitis, she said, and restoring the
natural microbial ecology may be a way of mitigating this common condition.
A Painful, Costly Condition

Sinuses are air-filled cavities in the front of the skull that connect
to the nasal passages and are lined with mucosal surfaces. They are
somewhat shrouded in mystery. Scientists are not entirely sure what they
do. They may exist to heat air as it passes into the body, they may be
associated with the immune system, or as Lynch and her colleagues
speculate, they may represent a site of microbial surveillance just
inside the nose where the body can sample bacteria and other microbes
entering the body.

Though the sinuses’ underlying purpose is still unclear, they are all
too familiar to American doctors and their patients because of what
happens when the thin tissues lining them become inflamed, as occurs in
chronic sinusitis — one of the most common reasons why people go to the
doctor in the United States. There are about 30 million cases each year,
and the cost to the healthcare system is an estimated $2.4 billion
dollars annually.

The pain of sinusitis can last for months. Doctors typically prescribe
bacteria-killing antibiotics and, in more severe and long-lasting cases,
conduct sinus surgeries. However, said Andrew Goldberg, MSCE, MD, the
director of rhinology and sinus surgery at UCSF and a co-author on the
paper, “the premise for our understanding of chronic sinusitis and
therapeutic treatment appears to be wrong, and a different therapeutic
strategy seems appropriate.”

The new work suggests that if the underlying cause of sinusitis is due
to changes to the microbiome of bacterial species colonizing sinus
tissue, restoring the naturally-occurring, protective bacteria to these
cavities may be an effective way to treat this condition.

However, the UCSF-led team warned that the promise of this discovery
does not offer an immediate new treatment or cure for sinusitis. Any new
approaches based on these observations still have to be developed and
tested for safety and effectiveness in human clinical trials.

The article, “Sinus Microbiome Diversity Depletion and Corynebacterium
tuberculostearicum Enrichment Mediates Rhinosinusitis” by Nicole A.
Abreu, Nabeetha A. Nagalingam, Yuanlin Song, Frederick C. Roediger,
Steven D. Pletcher, Andrew N. Goldberg, and Susan V. Lynch appears in
the September 12, 2012, issue of Science Translational Medicine.

In addition to UCSF, authors on this study are affiliated with San
Francisco State University, the University of California Berkley, and
Fudan University in Shanghai, China.

This study was supported by the American Rhinological Society, the
Rainin Foundation, the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious
Diseases (one of the National Institutes of Health), the Minority
Biomedical Research Support-Research Initiative for Scientific
Enhancement (MBRS-RISE), the California Institute for Regenerative
Medicine, and the Rebecca Susan Buffett Foundation.

Lynch is a member of the advisory board of Second Genome, which is
developing treatments for human diseases based on microbiome research,
and she is one of three co-authors on the paper who have filed a patent
application for sinusitis diagnostics and treatments.
a***@yahoo.fr
2012-09-15 20:18:47 UTC
Permalink
This really is a landmark article, but after reading it in whole and not just the abstract, I am not yet 100 percent convinced by the C. tuberculostearicum thing.

The article is sound and the experiment well-designed and documented, but :
- the cohort size is small (10 patients, 10 controls),
- Staph aureus was not tested (or else I missed something while searching the bug list with the pdf search feature),
- the CT-to-symptoms correlation is interesting and the strongest in the lot, but still not that powerful,
- grouping all the pseudomonas together might have put them on the culprit list.

BTW I am not a statistician, so I do not intend to underestimate the CT thing, all the more since the CT hypothesis was then tested and confirmed in mice, but I think more studies should say whether it really is a universal CRS culprit or just a common one, and it is certain that more than 10 patients are needed for that.

Anyway, it's a great article and helps pave the way for nasal probiotic sprays or microflora transplants.

-----------

Sci Transl Med. 2012 Sep 12;4(151):151ra124.
Sinus Microbiome Diversity Depletion and Corynebacterium tuberculostearicum Enrichment Mediates Rhinosinusitis.
Abreu NA, Nagalingam NA, Song Y, Roediger FC, Pletcher SD, Goldberg AN, Lynch SV.
Source
Department of Biology, San Francisco State University, Hensill 534, 1600 Holloway Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94132, USA.

Abstract
Persistent mucosal inflammation and microbial infection are characteristics of chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS). Mucosal microbiota dysbiosis is found in other chronic inflammatory diseases; however, the relationship between sinus microbiota composition and CRS is unknown. Using comparative microbiome profiling of a cohort of CRS patients and healthy subjects, we demonstrate that the sinus microbiota of CRS patients exhibits significantly reduced bacterial diversity compared with that of healthy controls. In our cohort of CRS patients, multiple, phylogenetically distinct lactic acid bacteria were depleted concomitant with an increase in the relative abundance of a single species, Corynebacterium tuberculostearicum. We recapitulated the conditions observed in our human cohort in a murine model and confirmed the pathogenic potential of C. tuberculostearicum and the critical necessity for a replete mucosal microbiota to protect against this species. Moreover, Lactobacillus sakei, which was identified from our comparative microbiome analyses as a potentially protective species, defended against C. tuberculostearicum sinus infection, even in the context of a depleted sinus bacterial community. These studies demonstrate that sinus mucosal health is highly dependent on the composition of the resident microbiota as well as identify both a new sino-pathogen and a strong bacterial candidate for therapeutic intervention.
Post by asdfasdf
This seems like it may hold some promise...
http://www.ucsf.edu/news/2012/09/12718/sinusitis-linked-microbial-diversity
Sinusitis Linked to Microbial Diversity
UCSF Study Suggests New Approach for Dealing with Common Ailment
Share
Print
By Jason Bardi on September 12, 2012
Email
A common bacteria ever-present on the human skin and previously
considered harmless, may, in fact, be the culprit behind chronic
sinusitis, a painful, recurring swelling of the sinuses that strikes
more than one in ten Americans each year, according to a study by
scientists at the University of California, San Francisco (UCSF).
Susan Lynch, PhD
Susan Lynch, PhD
The team reports this week in the journal Science Translational Medicine
that sinusitis may be linked to the loss of normal microbial diversity
within the sinuses following an infection and the subsequent
colonization of the sinuses by the culprit bacterium, which is called
Corynebacterium tuberculostearicum.
In their study, the researchers compared the microbial communities in
samples from the sinuses of 10 patients with sinusitis and from 10
healthy people, and showed that the sinusitis patients lacked a slew of
bacteria that were present in the healthy individuals. The patients also
had large increases in the amount of Corynebacterium tuberculostearicum
in their sinuses, which are located in the forehead, cheeks and eyes.
The team also identified a common bacterium found within the sinuses of
healthy people called Lactobacillus sakei that seems to help the body
naturally ward off sinusitis. In laboratory experiments, inoculating
mice with this one bacterium defended them against the condition.
“Presumably these are sinus-protective species,” said Susan Lynch, PhD,
an associate professor of medicine and director of the Colitis and
Crohn’s Disease Microbiome Research Core at UCSF.
What it all suggests, she added, is that the sinuses are home to a
diverse “microbiome” that includes protective bacteria. These “microbial
shields” are lost during chronic sinusitis, she said, and restoring the
natural microbial ecology may be a way of mitigating this common condition.
A Painful, Costly Condition
Sinuses are air-filled cavities in the front of the skull that connect
to the nasal passages and are lined with mucosal surfaces. They are
somewhat shrouded in mystery. Scientists are not entirely sure what they
do. They may exist to heat air as it passes into the body, they may be
associated with the immune system, or as Lynch and her colleagues
speculate, they may represent a site of microbial surveillance just
inside the nose where the body can sample bacteria and other microbes
entering the body.
Though the sinuses’ underlying purpose is still unclear, they are all
too familiar to American doctors and their patients because of what
happens when the thin tissues lining them become inflamed, as occurs in
chronic sinusitis — one of the most common reasons why people go to the
doctor in the United States. There are about 30 million cases each year,
and the cost to the healthcare system is an estimated $2.4 billion
dollars annually.
The pain of sinusitis can last for months. Doctors typically prescribe
bacteria-killing antibiotics and, in more severe and long-lasting cases,
conduct sinus surgeries. However, said Andrew Goldberg, MSCE, MD, the
director of rhinology and sinus surgery at UCSF and a co-author on the
paper, “the premise for our understanding of chronic sinusitis and
therapeutic treatment appears to be wrong, and a different therapeutic
strategy seems appropriate.”
The new work suggests that if the underlying cause of sinusitis is due
to changes to the microbiome of bacterial species colonizing sinus
tissue, restoring the naturally-occurring, protective bacteria to these
cavities may be an effective way to treat this condition.
However, the UCSF-led team warned that the promise of this discovery
does not offer an immediate new treatment or cure for sinusitis. Any new
approaches based on these observations still have to be developed and
tested for safety and effectiveness in human clinical trials.
The article, “Sinus Microbiome Diversity Depletion and Corynebacterium
tuberculostearicum Enrichment Mediates Rhinosinusitis” by Nicole A.
Abreu, Nabeetha A. Nagalingam, Yuanlin Song, Frederick C. Roediger,
Steven D. Pletcher, Andrew N. Goldberg, and Susan V. Lynch appears in
the September 12, 2012, issue of Science Translational Medicine.
In addition to UCSF, authors on this study are affiliated with San
Francisco State University, the University of California Berkley, and
Fudan University in Shanghai, China.
This study was supported by the American Rhinological Society, the
Rainin Foundation, the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious
Diseases (one of the National Institutes of Health), the Minority
Biomedical Research Support-Research Initiative for Scientific
Enhancement (MBRS-RISE), the California Institute for Regenerative
Medicine, and the Rebecca Susan Buffett Foundation.
Lynch is a member of the advisory board of Second Genome, which is
developing treatments for human diseases based on microbiome research,
and she is one of three co-authors on the paper who have filed a patent
application for sinusitis diagnostics and treatments.
Steven L.
2012-09-24 18:03:40 UTC
Permalink
Post by a***@yahoo.fr
This really is a landmark article, but after reading it in whole and not just the abstract, I am not yet 100 percent convinced by the C. tuberculostearicum thing.
- the cohort size is small (10 patients, 10 controls),
- Staph aureus was not tested (or else I missed something while searching the bug list with the pdf search feature),
- the CT-to-symptoms correlation is interesting and the strongest in the lot, but still not that powerful,
- grouping all the pseudomonas together might have put them on the culprit list.
Another problem is that there have already been too many "definitive
causes of sinusitis" that scientists have claimed to have discovered.
Usually they end up getting debunked eventually.

In the 1990s, the Mayo Clinic had announced that their research "showed"
that 95% of chronic sinusitis cases were caused by an allergic reaction
to a fungus (allergic fungal sinusitis). But in the years that followed,
Mayo had to back off that claim. Today, scientists believe that AFS is
responsible for no more than 10% (at most) of cases of chronic sinusitis.

ENTs have told me that they believe that there won't be one sweeping
underlying cause of chronic sinusitis, any more than there is just one
cause of cancer. Rather, like cancer, sinusitis will turn out to be a
cluster of different diseases--each with its own cause--under the same
umbrella term "chronic sinusitis".
--
Steven L.
l' acrobate
2012-09-30 01:57:02 UTC
Permalink
I find this fascinating and it seems consistent with larger trends in scientific research.

If you have time, this is a very worthy hour: http://onpoint.wbur.org/2012/06/20/bacteria-2

I believe "good bacteria" will be the future in every field of medicine. I just fear how much damage has been done to my body with antibiotics.

md

Loading...